Valuation
Andrea Minardi Antônio Zoratto Sanvicente Carlos Mauro Gali Montenegro Danielle Hatem Donatelli Fernando Graciano Bignotto
IBMEC WORKING PAPER - WPE – 33 - 2007
! " # ! ! ! ! (%) ' ( ) %* & ) +( ) ) %&' ( )) )'% ( )' * +%' ! * , * + ( & % & %))'% . * ' / * * ) &' +( +(% * + ( %' ' &' ! ( * & %( %) * , * ) ( () ) %&' (& ) * (0 &%1 . *%2 ()%3% * 4 *%( * ) + &5 ( & ( ( !5 ( ) / '%2 )4 ' + ) )) & % %) + ( !%&5 ( )'( '60% * +( ) (0 &%1 . (% . * 2 ! ( + ( % &%)' - /%)' + !7 % ( 1 82 ! ) ( * ' ( %& ( ) + (9 '( ) * : ;4 * ! %) '%!%1 * + ( )'% ( )' * +%' ! +( )4
*%* ) * * ) ! ( )' * 3 &.
J& ) +( + ( % & ! &' 6 ) + (% ( )' * * ' ( +%' ! * &' &* (%) ( ! . +%' !
&J % 4 + & ) ) +%' !* (%) 6
)' 6 + )%'%2 4
) @ 4
( ' (& * %&2 )'% + ( . * , * *
%' % + (' &' 4 + %) 3 ' (8 &' 4 )'( '60% * ) (%) 4 ) * ( +( ) +( ) &' *
%& &'%2 * ) / )' ' &* (8 3 ' )'% %'8B!
'%2 ) * *
+( @ ' ) 4 +( @ ' 3 ( ' ' !4 &
&) ,K &' %'
%/ 4 * *
% ( + (' * ) 2 1 ) ) +( ) ' &* (8 ( ( @ %' (
)' 3 ( !'
(%) 4
+( @ ' ,
+ * (% ) ( )'( ' 0% + '%'%2 ) $ )'% . * )' *
&' %&' ( )) &' 4 + %)4 $ + )%'%2 4 ' &* (%
+( @ ' + * )) '( 1 ( 2 &' 0 &) ) ( ( @ %' * + ( + ( . (( * *
*%* ) + ( )
+%' !4 +(%& %+ ! * ! 4
&' )'%
* (
+%' ! * )' * *
% &%)' 4 6 +%' ! +( ) ( )%! %( )N & ) . * +( ) ) *
$ 6 +( + )'
' * ! 0% + (
+%' ! 3 5 *
&%* * ) * & 0< % )4
& ) .
)' * 6
& ! =* -
-
)'
6*% *
+%' ! + &* ( * :F
;
)' *
+%' ! +( ,
&' -
( %)) 4
+( @ ' ) (8 L
3%& & % * %&' 0( ! 3%& & % ,
&'
+%' ! +( ) +%' ! * )
) )' &' ( ) )'
+ !='% ( 0 + (M
)'( ' ( *
+( ) )-
& %( 4 + * B)
0R
×
:X;
&* ( ' &. ( ' (&
6
( ' (& ) ( (( )+ &*
+ '(% J&% !=, %* 4 B' / * + 0 ( *
6 ' / * ( ' &. &' * *%2%* &* )-
* ! ( )-
' / *
* ! ( ) )+ ( * *
(' %( *
:( ; + * ) ( )'% $
*